Barry Rubin, Op-ed to Washington Post
To the Editor:
As editor of the Middle East Review of International Affairs (MERIA) Journal,
I must correct inaccurate
statements about my magazine made in the Washington Post article, February 8,
regarding the British
government's plagiarism of our material. Your article states the British
government paper was based on
12-year-old research by Ibrahim Marashi. In fact, Mr. Marashi used documents
captured from Iraq in 1991 but the research was done recently. All material in
his article, "Iraq's Security and Intelligence Network: A Guide and
Analysis," was updated to reflect changes in Iraq's intelligence apparatus.
Your article also mistakenly stages that sections were copied from an article by
Glen Rangwala in our journal. In fact, Dr. Rangwala was the reader who
discovered the plagiarismof Mr. Marashi's work.
We believe that the article and its information was of the highest
quality and deserved the wide
distribution it received and the praise from Secretary of State Colin Powell.
The only problem is that the
Prime Minister's office did not credit us and Mr.Marashi for our work. Anyone
wishing to see the
original article can do so at http://meria.idc.ac.il.
Professor Barry Rubin, Editor, MERIA Journal